Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Episode 4, The Dates


I had a bit of an inner struggle this week trying to sort out whether to focus on Sean or the dates. Both were just so boring, and the combination of the two interest voids made for a very slow two hours of TV. But ultimately, I decided, misogynistic statements aside ("You're basically just asking me to kiss you;" "You should do it. I think you can do it;" "I can't allow you to continue."), it was Sean that rendered the dates drama-less and dull, so I gave the nod to the events over the man. I still can't decided if I'd rather date Sean, spend two hours lost in the desert, break my jaw, or be treated like a famed movie hooker, but at least Sean would probably find some honey-dipped way to patronize me no matter which I chose.  

Rock Climbing in the Desert
So, my heart goes out to Selma on this one because I too am not really an "outdoorsy" kind of person. If it's 75 and sunny, I might be up for a picnic outing or some reading on the deck, but if we're talking mid-80's or higher, all I'm going to be capable of is stewing in my own sweat. Being an outdoor person is kind of like being a morning person. Though it's really a value-neutral lifestyle choice, it endows people with an inexplicable power to judge those who don't subscribe. The opposite of an outdoor person isn't an indoor kid (which conjures up an unflattering enough image as it is, involving perpetual nasal congestion and pale skin), but a lazy person, as if there's no industrious pursuit available to commit oneself to away from the great outdoors. Selma's not lazy (I assume - any woman who looks that put together in yoga gear is at least putting effort into something), so why must she be punished for not wanting to spend half her date with sweat populating every crevice in her entire body rather than just the classic first date armpits?

All this being said and sympathies to Selma aside, I do think Sean made a valid point by bringing Selma on this date. Annoyingly outdoorsy men usually do best with annoyingly outdoorsy wives. If he loves hiking, he needs a woman who will go hiking, even if it's 90 degrees and there's a Making Mr. Right marathon waiting for them in the air conditioning. I don't fault him for putting Selma through the ringer, but I do fault the show (and perhaps Sean's dreamy muscles), for creating a climate in which Selma can't be honest about what she's into. It horrifies me to think what reality television has come to if it's okay to make clear that you're not up for a quick lip lock, but not okay to say that you'll pass on the fresh air.

The Roller Derby Date
I swear, next week the group date is going to be "Stabbing each other with broken shards of glass." So desperate are the producers to stir up drama between these charming, plastic housemates, that they're doing everything short of arming them with hand grenades and bayonets. It seems like every time the producers set the show up for something big emotionally, Sean pulls the rug out from under them. First, he refused to allow the prank on Desiree to percolate, making the big reveal before the bemused smile ever left her face, and now he puts the kibosh on the chick fight on wheels. Sean's lack of concern for us, the television audience, might make him a fine husband, but it certainly doesn't make him a very good watch.



The Pretty Woman Date
I know this may be kind of surprising, but I don't consider myself a feminist (I know, it's incredibly hard to believe that someone who devotes this much time to The Bachelor each week isn't a bra-burning sister of Betty Friedan, but it's true!). But I swear, if one more person, male or female, suggests that playing Julia Robert's role in Pretty Woman is every girl's dream, I might start some sort of ex post facto suffragettes campaign. Let's leave aside for a moment the fact that Julia Roberts was a prostitute in that movie and that she had to deal with aggressively handsy Jason Alexander. I'm pretty sure having a man (or even a successful reality television franchise) buy you lots of things isn't every little girl's dream. Some little girls want to be astronauts or marine biologists. Others want to invent the next flavor of soda or play soccer for Team USA. Hell, other little girls are so spoiled that they wouldn't have space for the dress and the diamonds behind their dollhouse, and their stuffed animals, and their pony. And yes, I would prefer Leslie's date to any of the other physically-daunting, motion sickness-inducing, bikini-mandatory dates that have been trotted out this season. And yes, if I'm going to be sent packing, I might as well get sent on my merry way with something I can sell on ebay (and how lucky for Leslie that she lives in Vegas where at least pawn shops aren't hard to come by). But as someone who used to be a little girl, I believe I can speak for all of us when I say we dream bigger than this.

The Show, An Interlude

Did I scare you?  Did you look at the picture above and think "how can there still be three girls I don't recognize when we're already in Episode 4?  Have they been trapped in the Bachelor mansion dungeon?"  Or maybe you weren't even alarmed. Maybe you just thought, "Wait, which one is Jackie again?"

The answers are that none of them is Jacki (but if anyone finds out what Jackie looks like or, better yet, actually hears her voice, can you let me know?), and none of them is actually on The Bachelor. Instead, these are the ladies from VH1's Making Mr. Right, and they've given me an excuse to take a break from the recap coverage to make a brief public service announcement.

I know we're not really in a reality dating show draught right now.  There are two episodes of The Bachelor next week (my poor blogging fingers ache at the thought!), and that Eva Longoria join has to be launching soon (or maybe it already started? I must confess to being behind on all things Longoria*). But this show is well worth a watch.

The concept is simple: Three girls and 12-odd guys live in a house. The girls pretend to be professional matchmakers - setting the guys up on dates and giving them advice - while spying on them at each step of the way, judging the men's performance and looking for matches of their own. There's also a real matchmaker swanning about, I'm sure serving some purpose I haven't quite figured out. (I'm sorry - did I say simple? I meant really, really complicated).  The stakes are high (or maybe they're not - as far as I can tell sometimes men get sent home, but not on any sort of consistent timetable or in a dramatically soundtracked ceremony of any kind), and the potential for disaster is even higher. And as this season of The Bachelor limps to a boring conclusion (seriously, after the 3rd overly dramatic minor injury, I only have so much emotional investment left to give), it might be exactly what you need to get your TV dating show ridiculousness fix.


*That includes you, Evan. I just can't get behind the Tampa Bay Rays this year.

Saturday, January 26, 2013

Episode 3, The Scores

Amanda Amanda - 15
+5 for a rose
Bonus: +10 for saying she would "do whatever it takes"
AshLee F.



 AshLee - 55
+5 for crying
+5 for kissing on a one-on-one
+10 for revealing a personal tragedy
+20 for a date rose
Bonus: +15 for making Sean cry. That guy was like stone on Emily's season!
Catherine

Catherine - 5
+5 for a rose

Daniella
 Daniella - 10
+5 for a rose
Bonus: +5 for misusing the word literally, again. Unless she actually weaks up in a cold sweat after dreaming about beach volleyball. I don't know her life.
  
Desiree
Desiree - 55
+5 for rose
+5 for crying
+10 x 2 for date kissing on both the group date and at the cocktail party
+10 for questioning if Amanda is "there for the right reasons"
+15 for having Sean comment on her attractiveness

Jackie Jackie - 5    
+5 for a rose




Kacie
Kacie - 35
Eliminated
+5 for crying
Bonus: +30 for Sean actually calling her a crazy person. I'm not sure this has ever happened in Bachelor history, and ladies have done a lot of crazy nonsense.

Kristy Kristy - 10
Eliminated
+5 x 2 for crying twice



Lesley
 Lesley M. - 35
+20 for a date rose
+5 for kissing on a 1-on-1
+10 for making Sean blush
Bonus: I would award Lesley -50 for saying that she "enjoyed" middle school if I gave negative points.

Leslie
Leslie H. - 10
+5 for rose
+5 for crying

Lindsay
Lindsay - 30
+20 for a date rose
+10 for kissing on a group date
  
Robyn
Robyn - 5
+5 for rose

Sarah Sarah - 20   
+5 for a rose
Bonus: +15 for receiving a gift from Sean



Selma

Selma - 5
+5 for a rose



Taryn
 Taryn - 15
Eliminated
+5 for crying
Bonus: +10 for having her priorities all out of whack with the importance of that volleyball game

Tierra

Tierra - 40
+5 for a rose
+25 for requiring a vehicle with an ambulance
+5 for playing a prank on AshLee and Selma with the 2-on-1
+5 for crying





Friday, January 25, 2013

Episode 3, The Drama

The Situation: Kacie's revelation of tension between Desiree and Amanda
How Dramatic Was It? If drama's unit of measurement was the horrified cringe, then this would have been the most dramatic moment in Bachelor history. As it turns out, though, it was actually just really awkward. At least it gave Sean an opportunity to demonstrate that he didn't "have too much respect" for Kristy and Taryn to send them home during the rose ceremony.
Who's to Blame? Kacie.  And the American public school system. You guys, we have to stop teaching to the test and start focusing on critical reasoning.


The Situation: Tierra's Dive
How Dramatic Was It? Actually, pretty dramatic. This was a very rare incident where ABC's "coming up" build up actually proved to be less intriguing than the actual event. I don't want to see Tierra get hurt while the other women express breathy concern and make future stabs at stealing the spotlight from her sick bed. I want to see Tierra fake injury while the women express concern for approximately 30 secondary followed by (I imagine) hours of catty accusations. Also, hasn't ABC learned yet that we're gonna keep watching even without all the build up? You don't see drug dealers spending money on marketing campaigns, do you?
Who's to Blame? Tierra...and gravity. Not necessarily in that order. It's really, really hard to purposefully throw yourself down a flight of stairs. Not that I know from personal experience, but anyone who's ever watched a daytime soap can tell you that it takes great inner reserves of strength and an expected outcome far more nefarious than an extra five minutes with Sean. (Seriously, you save that move for when you're preventing the Count from discovering that you only had facial reconstructive surgery to look like his wife). What I suspect happened is that Tierra actually fell and then played up how injured she was until the ambulance showed up. Either that or a bored producer greased the stairs.
How Impressed would Noted Footballer and Diver Cristiano Ronaldo be? Probably very.  She got the call then got right back in the game. That's World Cup calibre stuff!

The Situation: The Final Rose
How Dramatic Was It? Not dramatic at all. Get your act together ABC editors!  We've already seen Desiree in scenes from coming weeks.

Episode 3, An Interlude



"Now I just feel like a pimp."
                    - Sean Lowe

Really, Sean?  Now you just feel like a pimp?  Not when ABC surrounded with 25 women willing to sleep with you for a brief shot at fame and a chance to maybe meet the muppets?

I'm no expert on the seedy underbelly of the streets, but I'm guessing most pimps don't define themselves by their number of boas.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

Episode 3, The Girls

Is it just me, or are women falling head over heels a bit early this year? It's not that I question the process or believe that you can't fall in love after a single formulaic conversation and some light canoodling. I would never doubt Chris Harrison in such a way. Bur if things keep moving at this pace, by episode 4, Sean will be using his action figure physique to dodge a veritable fire storm of L-bombs.

With happy endings looming large on their minds, the women have started to loosen the vise grips they've been relying on to hold back their crazy, and we're all so happy that they have. In descending order of craziness, here are this week's notable performances.

Kacie: I feel more than a little bit bad for Kacie. She was lovable, sweet, and the clear correct choice on Ben's season, and then she got cheated out of her ascendancy to the Bachelorette throne by Emily Maynard's healed heartbreak. As I've stated before, I actually kind of believe that she came back because she was really interested in Sean, but I don't believe he was ever going to let her out of the friend zone. Instead of strolling out of the mansion on her way to the alter or a more firmly rooted place in America's collective heart (or even whatever country's tourism board is desperate enough to partner with ABC this season - I'm guessing Somalia), Kacie left as a bizarrely manipulative crazy lady whose propensity for showing cleavage ranked top on her list of redeeming features. And while it makes me sad that she's leaving with her nice girl image in tatters, I suppose you can't feel too bad for any girl attempting to steal a move from the Courtney Robertson's playbook. It says right on the cover "non-models and non-evil geniuses need not apply."

Tierra: This week, Sean proved he's not stupid. I'm pretty sure he was able to see though both Kacie and Tierra's desperate manipulations with equal degrees of clarity. But Tierra proved this week that Sean's clearly willing to overlook these obvious ploys if he really, really wants to sleep with you. While Tierra won herself some extra time with Sean, this strategy doesn't have legs in the long term. Because, as my husband will gladly tell you, repeatedly taking your clumsy wife to the emergency room gets more than a little old.

AshLee: Now, hear me out here. I know AshLee doesn't yet seem that crazy. After some, probably totally justified cattiness toward Tierra, she and Sean enjoyed a completely lovely date. Old timey costumes we donned! Broken children were healed by proximity to Sean's pecs! Adolescents were forced to amuse themselves while Sean and AshLee selfishly slow-danced! But over the course of the date, AshLee began to expose more than just her upper thighs (seriously - why does no one give the ladies a heads up when their dates might warrant just a little bit of extra coverage), revealing a personal tragedy that Sean found inspiring and moving and that I just found really, really upsetting.

"I lived with a family who abused me," she said. "Isn't that crazy?" No, AshLee. It's crazy when you see Alex Trebec on an airplane. It's crazy when a staunch "family values" conservative is revealed to be a transvestite. Child abuse and the deplorable state of our foster care system aren't "crazy." They're really, really horrible.

AshLee later revealed that Sean was the only man with whom she had ever shared her painful past. And my guess is that this is because she's well on her way to becoming this season's clinger. After confessing that she's already falling for Sean, she's certainly a frontrunner for the role of girl who falls too far too fast and spends most of her screentime for the rest of the season in mascara-laced tears. All that being said, it's also totally possible that the conditions of the show are to blame for AshLee's early revelation. Every year, the contestants are forced to play a kind of chicken with their personal tragedies. They're pushed to use them as leverage to win roses and the right to stick around, but they can't appear to be too damaged. There's a reason people wait to share their lives' hardships with the people they date. It's so they don't have to explain them away. Though people's personalities are absolutely informed by their triumph over adversity, one can't help but feel like adversity can only be compounded by having to explain that "it wasn't that bad."

Amanda: Look, I'm not saying that I want to go grab a beer with Amanda (mostly because, as she's a fit model, I imagine I'd be doing all the beer-drinking while she'd be sitting in silence, judging all the parts of me that jiggle), but I'm still not really buying this "she's here for the wrongs reasons" theme that the other girls keep harping on. Yes, she's said a few rather aggressive things about doing whatever it takes and winning the rose for being awesome at, not just volleyball but life, but she's not exactly incorrect to say that some of the other girls think they have a stronger connection with Sean than they really do. Is she sunshine and rainbows? No, she is not. Would she be my first choice to co-star with in an 80's movie montage where we tried on wacky hats? Certainly not. But is she a soul-sucking, uber-bitch who's only on the show to get her 15 minutes of fame, Sean's heart be damned? Well...okay, probably yes. But no more so that anybody else on this franchise.

Desiree: Desiree may look like a young Katie Holmes (does it make anyone else feel super ancient that I just said young Katie Holmes), but apparently she doesn't think like anyone else. This is a clear-cut example of what I like to refer to as the Chris Bukowski principle (aka The "Grown-Ass Man" Principle): If you have to say it aloud, it probably isn't true.

Sarah: Unfortunately, when it comes to Sarah, I think Sean's in a little bit of a tough spot. I believe that he likes her, and thinks she's beautiful, and fully believes her capable of ziplining or any other activity outlawed by the state of Nevada (such as, apparently, riding a camel on the highway), but I don't think he has the same chemistry with her as he does with some of the other girls. I'm sure it's not because of her disability - maybe it's the incessant, nasal "Oh my gods," or maybe it's because she's not a brunette - but when he eventually sends her home, all that's unlike to matter. To me, when Sean brought out Sarah's dog this week, it was less of a romantic gesture and more of a preemptive apology. How else do you explain that poor Sarah got further with the dog this week than she did with the man himself.

Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Episode 3, The Dates


Well, it's official. We're three weeks in and I've already run out of things to say about Sean. I could write another post filled with blah, blah, blah muscles; blah, blah, blah manly; blah, blah, blah terrible life decisions. But instead I've chosen to shift my focus to something that truly is inspiring in the depths of its terribleness. This season's dates!

Though probably every woman who goes on the Bachelor secretly believes she's going to win and live a life defined by six months of infamy and the world's least romantic engagement, those that don't should at least expect to console themselves with luxurious clothing purchased for them in a "reformed prostitute" style date, memories of no less than $25,000 worth of fireworks exploded in their honor, or a slight itchy feeling that probably originated in some hot tub. But the women of this season have been pranked, reminded of childhood traumas, made to play dress up, and generally disappointed (which, if Sean's faith holds fast, is a trend that will likely continue through fantasy suite week), and things certainly weren't looking up this week.

The Bathroom Break Date

Also known as "The Longest Screen Kiss Ever" Date, this date gave me all kinds of opportunities to file my nails, make an important telephone call to dentist, and do some light core work (by which I mean make and eat a sandwich). While I'm sure the experience was much more pleasant for Lesley than it was for the television audience, there's no denying that this date was awkward. And I can't help thinking that she must have spent at least half of that kiss wishing someone had warned her to wear a longer dress.

Pretending that I haven't happened upon any spoilers for a moment, Lesley M. better be the future Lesley L. because no woman wants to marry a man who holds a kissing record with some other girl.

The Beach Volleyball Date

Apparently the producers also noticed the dearth of crying in last week's episode because a competition group date in which half of the women go home is a surefire way to make it rain (tears, not dollar bills - though I imagine a gathering of Bachelor castoffs isn't a bad way to get some stripping going either). It seems like a production company organized enough to provide the ladies with semi-matching bathing suits could have given Chris Harrison a heads up that he'd be going to the beach, but otherwise the date wrought just enough drama and devastation to keep it interesting.  I'd sum it up, but I think Taryn already did that more than admirably.

Taryn: This volleyball game is the most important game of my life. It's probably one of the only few [games] played that has something big riding on it.
She may have been sent packing, but Sean lost a real insightful one.  Taryn, when you're right, you're right!


The Amusement Park Date

Can I mock a date that involves a day of fun and friendship for a couple of really nice teens with chronic illnesses? I cannot. But I can say that a willingness to participate in public service does not necessarily make one a good person. While AshLee seemed legitimately sweet with the girls, it must be said that the greater act of charity would have been kindness toward the bitchy girl who took a tumble down the stairs, and that was an occasion to which AshLee certainly didn't see fit to rise.

Saturday, January 19, 2013

Episode 2, The Scores

Amanda Amanda - 5
+5 for a rose
AshLee F. AshLee - 5
+5 for a rose
Brooke
Brooke - 0
Eliminated 
Catherine
Catherine - 10
+5 for a rose
Bonus: +5 for saying "this is becoming more real."
Daniella
 Daniella - 15
+5 for a rose
+5 for light intoxication
Bonus: +5 for misusing the word literally
  
Desiree
Desiree - 30
+20 for date rose
+5 x 2 for kissing on a one-on-one in a hot tub

Diana Diana - 0    
Eliminated 
                                     
Jackie Jackie - 5    
+5 for a rose
Kacie
KacieKatie  - 20
+20 for a date rose




Katie - 50
+50 for leaving the show

Kristy Kristy - 35
+5 for a rose
+30 for plugging her modeling career...repeatedly
Lesley Lesley M. - 15
+5 for a rose
+10 for kissing on a group date
Leslie
Leslie H. - 10Lindsay Robyn
+5 for a rose
Bonus: +5 for wearing a glorified figure skating costume




Lindsay - 5
+5 for a rose





Robyn - 15
+5 for a rose
Bonus: +10 for talking about another girl behind her back with someone not officially part of the show
Sarah
Sarah - 50
+20 for a date rose
+5 for kissing on a one-on-one
+15 for having Sean comment on her attractiveness
+10 for revealing a personal tragedy (though this was technically revealed night 1 - I'm counting the zip line story) 
Selma Selma - 5
+5 for a rose
  

Taryn Tierra
Taryn - 5
+5 for a rose





Tierra - 15
+5 for a rose
+10 for saying "I didn't come here to make friends."

Episode 2, The Drama



The Situation: Katie Going Home
How Dramatic Was It? As undramatic as it gets.  Katie wasn't upset. Sean wasn't upset. Chris Harrison didn't even make an appearance to feign fatherly concern.
Who's to Blame? Sean.  If he hadn't really meant it when he said this was a two-way street - if he hadn't allowed Katie to go - this never would have happened.  Or perhaps Chris Harrison forgot to tell him about the dungeon.



The Situation: Desiree Breaking the Art
How Dramatic Was It? Again, not really. Desiree either knew about the prank in advance, or thought that art was so ugly that she was glad to see it go. Desiree's reaction to seeing that Pier 1 Import craft project break was only a shade less happy that her reaction to the "gallery owner" thinking her famous enough to have her picture taken with the art.
Who's to Blame? Bob Saget or whoever else it was that made baby Sean think that pranks were hilarious. Also, probably Sean's parents for allowing him to believe that he was funny.  Neither of these things are true.



The Situation: The Final Rose
How Dramatic Was It? A little bit, maybe? I think Amanda was on the group date, and waiting until the cocktail party to establish her bitchiness didn't give me enough time to emotionally invest.  Also, I'm done buying the "She's a totally different person around us and around Sean. I just wish he'd see her true colors" line. Is it really more fake not to befriend the 18 women who are fighting to win over your boyfriend?
Who's to Blame? The producers and post-production team, definitely. Now, it's possible that Amanda was sitting on the couch looking pissy and refusing to talk to anyone all night, but it's also possible that this sulkiness was made more extreme in editing. If my two Virginia drivers' license photos are to be believed, than it is certainly more than possible to capture a perfectly nice person on film making a very bitchy face. My guess is that Amanda was a little less than warm with the other girls, and it was the producers who decided to play it up like she flat out wasn't talking.  Or maybe she really wasn't talking, but it was for a really good reason. Maybe she spent the night trying not to vomit as the stench of 18 cloying perfumes comingled in a dense cloud of disgusting over the mansion living room. You have to think that's a problem.  In any case, I'm no more ready to throw Amanda to the wolves than I am Tierra.  Let's hope next week they do something truly heinous to prove me wrong.